We may indeed be living in the era of Peak Television, in terms of the proliferation of offerings on broadcast, cable and streaming — but if you’re counting shows for the whole family, especially scripted ones, pickings can be slim. But the Emmy nominations, released on Thursday, July 13, did manage to find some of the bright spots.
The 69th Annual Primetime Emmy Awards come out on Sunday, Sept. 17, and here are some of the family-oriented or family-friendly shows up for honors:
While neither show is squeaky-clean in the tradition of “My Three Sons” or “Happy Days,” and both contain elements that may require conversations in Catholic families, ABC’s “black-ish” and “Modern Family” receive generally high marks for tackling a wide variety of contemporary family issues without being overly sensational. In 2015, the Vatican even recognized “Modern Family” as a show with worthy elements.
While the nominees here tend toward the edgy, standing out are Netflix’s “The Crown,” a fascinating look at the life of Britain’s Elizabeth II, just before and after she becomes queen. No less than Bishop Robert Barron lauded the show for its depiction of both the difficulties and importance of Christian values (for which, regardless of the direction of the Anglican Church, Elizabeth II has always promoted).
Also nominated is NBC’s excellent family drama “This Is Us,” which had reduced many adults — including hard-bitten TV critics — to tears, with its heartfelt depiction of two generations of a family hit by loss by enriched by adoption.
The nomination also represents the first time in five years that a broadcast network has had a best-drama contender … and it’s with a family-oriented show! Here’s to hoping that this sparks development of more warmhearted shows on the broadcast networks — in the vein of “Highway to Heaven,” “The Waltons” or “Touched by an Angel” but we haven’t exactly seen it yet.
Because of broadcast standards and a different business model, it’s going to be near-impossible for ABC, NBC, CBS and even Fox to compete with the expensive, edgy shows coming out on cable on streaming services. So maybe they should stop trying and just go back to being BROADcasters, and program for the vast middle of America.
They might even make enough money to survive.
Thrilled and a bit surprised to see NBC’s “Dolly Parton’s Christmas of Many Colors: Circle of Love” among the nominees. First of all, TV-movies on broadcast networks are increasingly rare, and this one is a sequel to the previous year’s ratings hit “Dolly Parton’s Christmas of Many Colors.” Both movies — inspired by a Parton song, and based on her childhood in rural Tennessee — celebrate faith and family in a warmhearted yet realistic way. Here’s to hoping more broadcast nets decide to get back into the business of making not only family-suitable shows, but movies as well.
Hallmark may own this space at the moment, but that’s hardly set in stone.
UNSTRUCTURED REALITY PROGRAM
A&E’s “Born This Way” celebrates the joys and challenges of young adults who have Down Syndrome, and has become a critical and ratings hit. It’s a sad day when you need a TV show to show the human face of human beings, but we live in a world where many, if not most, people with this genetic condition never make it to their birthday.
I’ve seen huge billboards for this show in the busiest tourist areas of Hollywood Boulevard, and it’s great to see Emmy voters putting it into contention.
REALITY COMPETITION SHOW
It’s in the reality genre that parents find many shows to share with their children, and this group has several, such as CBS’ “The Amazing Race,” NBC’s “American Ninja Warrior,” Bravo’s “Top Chef” and NBC’s “The Voice.”
In particular, “The Voice” and “American Ninja Warrior” have proved to be friendly to contestants of faith, and that’s always appreciated.
So, when someone tells you that there’s nothing good on TV anymore, it’s just not true — and we congratulate Emmy voters on recognizing family-suitable fare as part of the quality mix.
Image: Courtesy ITU Pictures